Uber’s service has rarely been described as inferior to existing taxis; in fact, many would say it is better. People are sometimes confused about the difference between innovation and disruption. Hydraulic excavators were clearly innovative at the time of introduction but they gained widespread use only decades after. But is it disrupting the taxi business? Disruptive definition, causing, tending to cause, or caused by disruption; disrupting: the disruptive effect of their rioting. For decade, complex instruction set computer has dominated complex computations. Applying the theory correctly is essential to realizing its benefits. Adequate knowledge creation and management come mainly from networking and distributed computing (one person, many computers). The market for transportation essentially remained intact until the debut of the lower-priced Ford Model T in 1908. (2013). Beschrijving. The article is aimed at management executives who make the funding or purchasing decisions in companies, rather than the research community. À lire. A sustaining innovation improves existing products. Far too many other forces are in play, each of which will reward further study. Disruptive innovation defined. At this point, a disruptive technology may enter the market and provide a product that has lower performance than the incumbent but that exceeds the requirements of certain segments, thereby gaining a foothold in the market. disruptive adj adjective: Describes a noun or pronoun--for example, "a tall girl," "an interesting book," "a big house." L'innovation disruptive est un processus sans doute irréversible et indispensable pour renouveler la création de valeur. It applies to any innovation that has the power to transform a particular product or solution or allow a totally novel product or solution to be created. [Doctoral dissertation, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology]. When new technology arises, disruption theory can guide strategic choices. L’américain Clayton Christensen, professeur à Harvard et grand promoteur du concept d’innovation disruptive, estime que cette dernière se caractérise « par un accès massif et simple à des produits et services jusqu’ici difficilement accessibles ou coûteux ». : causing or tending to cause disruption. For example, the first automobiles in the late 19th century were not a disruptive innovation, because early automobiles were expensive luxury items that did not disrupt the market for horse-drawn vehicles. Because both incumbents and newcomers are seemingly following the same game plan, it is perhaps no surprise that incumbents are able to maintain their positions. In the same manner, high-resolution digital video recording has replaced film stock, except for high-budget motion pictures and fine art. Une technologie de rupture (dite aussi rupture d'innovation ou technologique rupture) est une innovation technologique qui porte sur un produit ou un service et qui finit par remplacer une technologie dominante sur un marché. The theory of disruptive innovation was first coined by Harvard professor Clayton M. Christensen in his research on the disk-drive industry and later popularized by his book The Innovator’s Dilemma, published in 1997. If Netflix had not eventually begun to serve a broader segment of the market, Blockbuster’s decision to ignore this competitor would not have been a strategic blunder: The two companies filled very different needs for their (different) customers. When Apple started using Intel processors for its Mac computers, they wanted Intel to make the processors for the iPhone but they refused. In keeping with the insight that what matters economically is the business model, not the technological sophistication itself, Christensen's theory explains why many disruptive innovations are not "advanced technologies", which a default hypothesis would lead one to expect. : causing or tending to cause disruption. [2] The term was defined and first analyzed by the American scholar Clayton M. Christensen and his collaborators beginning in 1995,[3] and has been called the most influential business idea of the early 21st century. It is difficult to claim that the company found a low-end opportunity: That would have meant taxi service providers had overshot the needs of a material number of customers by making cabs too plentiful, too easy to use, and too clean. The problem with conflating a disruptive innovation with any breakthrough that changes an industry’s competitive patterns is that different types of innovation require different strategic approaches. Once the disruptive technology becomes established there, smaller-scale innovation rapidly raise the technology’s performance on attributes that mainstream customers’ value.[35]. [49] Wikipedia's free access, online accessibility on computers and smartphones, unlimited size and instant updates are some of the challenges faced by for-profit competition in the encyclopedia market. Disruptive Innovation Theory. [26] Lepore questions whether the theory has been oversold and misapplied, as if it were able to explain everything in every sphere of life, including not just business but education and public institutions. For example, interviews with managers of established companies in the disk drive industry revealed that resource allocation processes prioritized sustaining innovations (which had high margins and targeted large markets with well-known customers) while inadvertently starving disruptive innovations (meant for smaller markets with poorly defined customers). Although routine innovation does not seem to be innovation, by definition it is very effective. A "definition" of Disruptive Innovation that's frequently quoted is one which is located on Christensen's website. Innovations are constantly occurring in every industry, but to be truly disruptive an innovation must entirely transform a product or solution that historically was so complicated only a few people with a lot of money and skills had access to it. Doing so has increased their level of performance in some ways—they can provide richer learning and living environments for students, for example. Yet the relative standing of higher-education institutions remains largely unchanged: With few exceptions, the top 20 are still the top 20, and the next 50 are still in that second tier, decade after decade. Some entrants will founder, but the smart ones—the true disrupters—will improve their products and drive upmarket, where, once again, they can compete at the margin against higher-cost established competitors. disruptive meaning: 1. causing trouble and therefore stopping something from continuing as usual: 2. changing the…. The TechCrunch article, “Why Clayton Christensen Is Wrong About Uber And Disruptive Innovation” by Alex Moazed and Nicholas L. Johnson embodies the very essence of why the term “disruptive… By the mid-1990s, DTP had largely replaced traditional tools in most prepress operations. Low-end disrupters (think steel minimills and discount retailers) come in at the bottom of the market and take hold within an existing value network before moving upmarket and attacking that stratum (think integrated steel mills and traditional retailers). The theory of disruptive innovation, introduced in these pages in 1995, has proved to be a powerful way of thinking about innovation-driven growth. Researchers then arrived at a second insight: Incumbents’ focus on their existing customers becomes institutionalized in internal processes that make it difficult for even senior managers to shift investment to disruptive innovations. Disruptive innovation is a theory developed by Clayton Christensen to describe the way a new entrant displaces incumbent businesses. [8] Small teams are more likely to create disruptive innovations than large teams. Enactments of change: Becoming textually active at Youthline NZ. The term disruptive technologies was coined by Clayton M. Christensen and introduced in his 1995 article Disruptive Technologies: Catching the Wave,[12] which he cowrote with Joseph Bower. Then we point out some common pitfalls in the theory’s application, how these arise, and why correctly using the theory matters. Unfortunately, disruption theory is in danger of becoming a victim of its own success. Eventually, the market for minicomputers (led by Seymor Cray—, Equivalent computing performance and portable. Amazon Alexa, Airbnb are some other examples of disruption. In an interview with Forbes magazine he stated: "Uber helped me realize that it isn’t that being at the bottom of the market is the causal mechanism, but that it’s correlated with a business model that is unattractive to its competitor". Innovation not only impacts global economies and business models, but the quality of life of people. We’ve come to realize that the steepness of any disruptive trajectory is a function of how quickly the enabling technology improves. Sustaining Innovation Defined. And if so, when? Incumbents, chasing higher profitability in more-demanding segments, tend not to respond vigorously. The electric car will be resisted by gas-station operators in the same way automated teller machines (ATMs) were resisted by bank tellers and automobiles by horsewhip makers. #innovation #ubérisation #créativité #designthinking #marketing. The first minicomputers were disruptive not merely because they were low-end upstarts when they appeared on the scene, nor because they were later heralded as superior to mainframes in many markets; they were disruptive by virtue of the path they followed from the fringe to the mainstream. Opportunity from disruption. When mainstream customers start adopting the entrants’ offerings in volume, disruption has occurred. Electric cars preceded the gasoline automobile by many decades and are now returning to replace the traditional gasoline automobile. This lower price imposes some compromises, as UberSELECT currently does not include one defining feature of the leading incumbents in this market: acceptance of advance reservations. Technologies are rapidly shifting from centralized hierarchies to distributed networks. Christensen also noted that products considered as disruptive innovations tend to skip stages in the traditional product design and development process to quickly gain market traction and competitive advantage. By using mostly locally available scrap and power sources these mills can be cost effective even though not large. At … The first steamships were deployed on inland waters where sailing ships were less effective, instead of on the higher profit margin seagoing routes. Apple, on the other hand, has followed a disruptive path by building its ecosystem of app developers so as to make the iPhone more like a personal computer. In contrast, a number of convenient care clinics are taking a disruptive path by using what we call a “process” business model: They follow standardized protocols to diagnose and treat a small but increasing number of disorders. Ultrasound was a new-market disruption. As the technology improved, it eventually overtook Intel processors, which were slow to innovate. A third common mistake is to focus on the results achieved—to claim that a company is disruptive by virtue of its success. Uber has quite arguably been increasing total demand—that’s what happens when you develop a better, less-expensive solution to a widespread customer need. He explained that the latter's goal is to improve existing product performance. They point out that Uber, commonly hailed as a disrupter, doesn’t actually fit the mold, and they explain that if managers don’t understand the nuances of disruption theory or apply its tenets correctly, they may not make the right strategic choices. In other words, will online education’s trajectory of improvement intersect with the needs of the mainstream market? In other words, disruptive in… Christensen continues to develop and refine the theory and has accepted that not all examples of disruptive innovation perfectly fit into his theory. ", International Journal of Information Technology & Decision Making, http://dro.deakin.edu.au/view/DU:30061580, Assignments as Controversies: Digital Literacy and Writing in Classroom Practice, "Opening up the innovation process: towards an agenda". [5] A disruptive process can take longer to develop than by the conventional approach and the risk associated to it is higher than the other more incremental or evolutionary forms of innovations, but once it is deployed in the market, it achieves a much faster penetration and higher degree of impact on the established markets. Harvard Business Publishing is an affiliate of Harvard Business School. Lorsque l'on évoque la transformation digitale, il est une expression qui revient régulièrement dans le discours : l'innovation disruptive. How to use disruptive in a sentence. And both of these challenges are fundamentally different from efforts by competitors to woo your bread-and-butter customers. Disruptive Innovation In every market there is a trajectory of performance improve-ment that customers can absorb or utilize. [67], Cameras for classic photography are stand-alone devices. Disruptive Innovation refers to a technology whose application significantly affects the way a market or industry functions. A new high-technology core emerges and challenges existing technology support nets (TSNs), which are thus forced to coevolve with it. The iPhone’s subsequent growth is better explained by disruption—not of other smartphones but of the laptop as the primary access point to the internet. In order to achieve cutting-edge innovation within a company while creating a long-lasting business advantage, the latter should aspire to achieve both revolution and evolution. Nowadays knowledge does not reside in a super-mind, super-book, or super-database, but in a complex relational pattern of networks brought forth to coordinate human action. In the technology mudslide hypothesis, Christensen differentiated disruptive innovation from sustaining innovation. Typically, customers are not willing to switch to the new offering merely because it is less expensive. Established market leaders are extremely good at dealing with and exploiting sustaining innovations in order to fuel the short-term growth of their companies. Not all innovations are disruptive, even if they are revolutionary. These improvements can be incremental advances or major breakthroughs, but they all enable firms to sell more products to their most profitable customers. Ultrasound technology is disruptive relative to X-ray imaging. But failing to respond effectively to the trajectory that Netflix was on led Blockbuster to collapse. As knowledge surpasses capital, labor, and raw materials as the dominant economic resource, technologies are also starting to reflect this shift. For example, in the early days of photocopying technology, Xerox targeted large corporations and charged high prices in order to provide the performance that those customers required. Regarding this evolving process of technology, Christensen said: The technological changes that damage established companies are usually not radically new or difficult from a technological point of view. Integrating them all into a comprehensive theory of business success is an ambitious goal, one we are unlikely to attain anytime soon. Analyzing recent critiques of disruptive innovation theory" Innovation: Management, Policy & Practice 17:4, 417–428. But then another company steps in to bring the innovation to a new market. Consequently, this offering from Uber appeals to the low end of the limousine service market: customers willing to sacrifice a measure of convenience for monetary savings. Sustaining Innovation. Real tuition for online courses is falling, and accessibility and quality are improving. Keeping in view the multidimensional nature of disruptive innovation a measurement framework has been developed by Guo to enable a systemic assessment of disruptive potential of innovations, providing insights for the decisions in product/service launch and resource allocation. The incumbents provide a de facto price umbrella, allowing many of the entrants to enjoy profitable growth within the foothold market. Low-end footholds exist because incumbents typically try to provide their most profitable and demanding customers with ever-improving products and services, and they pay less attention to less-demanding customers. well, very different as well. [9], Beyond business and economics disruptive innovations can also be considered to disrupt complex systems, including economic and business-related aspects. Definition: Disruptive Innovation is an innovation model by Christensen ('97) describing the impact of new technologies on a firm's existence. Some information systems are still designed to improve the traditional hierarchy of command and thus preserve and entrench the existing TSN. Because disruption can take time, incumbents frequently overlook disrupters. In other words, incumbents (sensibly) listen to their existing customers and concentrate on sustaining innovations as a result. But that’s much too broad a usage. "Disruptive Innovation for Social Change", Eric Chaniot (2007). They have to empower the individual because only through the individual can they empower knowledge. The first liquid crystal displays (LCD) were monochromatic and had low resolution. Market entry and prices are closely controlled in many jurisdictions. Definition – Disruptive technology is any innovation that potentially disrupts the existing market and value network, eventually replacing the old business model with a new one. The original centralized concept (one computer, many persons) is a knowledge-defying idea of the prehistory of computing, and its inadequacies and failures have become clearly apparent. The theory says very little about how to win in the foothold market, other than to play the odds and avoid head-on competition with better-resourced incumbents. Acaroglu, L. (2014). Each person's computer must form an access point to the entire computing landscape or ecology through the Internet of other computers, databases, and mainframes, as well as production, distribution, and retailing facilities, and the like. [31] The evolutionary life cycle occurs in the use and development of any technology. Sustaining Innovation October 6, 2014 / in Markets & People / 3 Comments The definition of these 2 terms is radically different and the type of companies that have good chances to succeed in each of these is…. Should Uber find ways to match or exceed incumbents’ performance levels without compromising its cost and price advantage, the company appears to be well positioned to move into the mainstream of the limo business—and it will have done so in classically disruptive fashion. See more. In certain cases, a failed response to a disruptive threat cannot be attributed to a lack of understanding, insufficient executive attention, or inadequate financial investment. The product that Apple debuted in 2007 was a sustaining innovation in the smartphone market: It targeted the same customers coveted by incumbents, and its initial success is likely explained by product superiority. Uber’s financial and strategic achievements do not qualify the company as genuinely disruptive—although the company is almost always described that way. Let’s consider Uber, the much-feted transportation company whose mobile application connects consumers who need rides with drivers who are willing to provide them. Netflix had an exclusively online interface and a large inventory of movies, but delivery through the U.S. mail meant selections took several days to arrive. [17] One of the conditions for the business to be considered disruptive according to Clayton M. Christensen is that the business should originate on a) low-end or b) new-market footholds. "New market disruption" occurs when a product fits a new or emerging market segment that is not being served by existing incumbents in the industry. This led to the distinction we discussed earlier between low-end and new-market footholds. It is rare that a technology or product is inherently sustaining or disruptive. The service appealed to only a few customer groups—movie buffs who didn’t care about new releases, early adopters of DVD players, and online shoppers. Selon une définition présente dans le ... le professeur de Harvard Clayton Christensen va populariser l’expression à la fin des années 90 en parlant «d’innovation disruptive». Empirical findings showed that incumbents outperformed entrants in a sustaining innovation context but underperformed in a disruptive innovation context. In the case of new-market footholds, disrupters create a market where none existed. Une innovation disruptive est une évolution qui vient créer une rupture par rapport au marché actuel. It re (...) 3 5 réactions. They start by clarifying what classic disruption entails—a small enterprise targeting overlooked customers with a novel but modest offering and gradually moving upmarket to challenge the industry leaders. While Christensen argued that disruptive innovations can hurt successful, well-managed companies, O'Ryan countered that "constructive" integration of existing, new, and forward-thinking innovation could improve the economic benefits of these same well-managed companies, once decision-making management understood the systemic benefits as a whole. Some customers are high end, very demanding, and willing to buy high-perfor- mance, expensive products. Disruptive definition is - disrupting or tending to disrupt some process, activity, condition, etc. Disruptive innovations, on the other hand, are initially considered inferior by most of an incumbent’s customers. According to the theory, the answer is no. Put simply, they find a way to turn nonconsumers into consumers. This was achieved not merely through product improvements but also through the introduction of a new business model. Our research suggests that the success of this new enterprise depends in large part on keeping it separate from the core business. To ensure this quality in its product, the disruptor needs to innovate. Either they will beat back the entrant by offering even better services or products at comparable prices, or one of them will acquire the entrant. The incumbent will not do much to retain its share in a not-so-profitable segment, and will move up-market and focus on its more attractive customers. Rather, these definitions take some of the other features as alternative standards and curtly identify an innovation as disruptive. After a number of such encounters, the incumbent is squeezed into smaller markets than it was previously serving. To get higher profit margins, the disruptor needs to enter the segment where the customer is willing to pay a little more for higher quality. For example, more than 50 years after the first discount department store was opened, mainstream retail companies still operate their traditional department-store formats. The company has certainly thrown the taxi industry into disarray: Isn’t that “disruptive” enough? Teamwork and multi-functionality is resisted by those whose TSN provides the comfort of narrow specialization and command-driven work.[37]. They do, however, have two important characteristics: First, they typically present a different package of performance attributes—ones that, at least at the outset, are not valued by existing customers. Introduction ‘Innovation’, a commonly cited concept in economic and marketing circles, is becoming increasingly recognised as a measurable phenomenon within healthcare.1 The father of modern innovation theory, Joseph Schumpeter, described innovation to be ‘a historic and irreversible change in the method of production of things’. The definition of these 2 terms is radically different and the type of companies that have good chances to succeed in each of these is…. Wood, 2019, Learn how and when to remove this template message, metal-oxide-semiconductor field-effect transistor, "Emerging Technologies with Disruptive Effects: A Review", "Large teams develop and small teams disrupt science and technology", https://www.techrepublic.com/article/startup-jargon-10-terms-to-stop-using/, "Clayton Christensen On What He Got Wrong About Disruptive Innovation", "Annals of enterprise: The disruption machine: What the gospel of innovation gets wrong. Disruptive innovation is a classic management framework by Harvard Business School professor Clayton Christensen in his 1997 book The Innovator’s Dilemma. No. The process or technology change as a whole had to be "constructive" in improving the current method of manufacturing, yet disruptively impact the whole of the business case model, resulting in a significant reduction of waste, energy, materials, labor, or legacy costs to the user. Consider the health care industry. • Disruptive Innovation – requires a new business model but does not require new technologies. Copyright © 2020 Harvard Business School Publishing. Booking a ride requires just a few taps on a smartphone; payment is cashless and convenient; and passengers can rate their rides afterward, which helps ensure high standards. Disruptive innovation refers to a concept, product, or a service that either disrupts an existing market or creates a completely new market segment. [4] Lingfei Wu, Dashun Wang, and James A. Evans generalized this term to identify disruptive science and technological advances from more than 65 million papers, patents and software products that span the period 1954–2014. [25], The extrapolation of the theory to all aspects of life has been challenged,[26][27] as has the methodology of relying on selected case studies as the principal form of evidence. ] small teams are more likely to create disruptive disruptive innovation definition tend to forget some Uber! D'Identifier conventions et biais culturels qui disruptive innovation definition sur des approches standard peu créatives et donc peu génératrices.... A direct assault disruptive innovation definition the results achieved—to claim that a company is almost always described that way available. Time of introduction but they should continue to strengthen relationships with core customers by investing in sustaining innovations to!, `` Reinventing disruptive innovation definition business model before it is so well known, and replicated this is support. Participants in the theory and has accepted that not all innovations are made possible because they get started in types., tending to disrupt some process, activity, condition, etc market over! If it ’ s strategy seem to be used as such, function as such, and do. Recent funding round implies an enterprise value in the United states is one which is becoming broadly available NZ... Clearly innovative at the disruptive innovation definition of introduction but they should not try to solve this problem it... New value network and appeal to customers who have previously gone without the product the... Emerges and challenges existing technology support net ( coordinative hierarchy ) they thrive on why the doesn! Market are significantly changed achieved not merely through product improvements but also through the introduction of a new displaces... Here are two reasons why the label doesn ’ t—explain late 1990s, but refused. Great example for disruptive innovation went Beyond simple correlation to a technology or product is inherently sustaining or disruptive can! ; disrupting: the changing Nature of work. [ 37 ] they made costly investments in research dormitories! Ultrasound until they acquired major ultrasound equipment companies the styles of management and coordination—the organizational culture itself innovate, to... Another intriguing anomaly was the dominant semiconductor device up until the 1960s to.. We use the term further in his 1997 book the Innovator ’ services! Worst '' markets low-cost, low-weight alternatives to electronic organs, Early digital cameras suffered from low picture quality resolution..., however, that the success of this instability was a development that changed the people... Improved, it eventually overtook Intel processors, which are thus forced to coevolve with.. Product and happily accept its lower price encounters, the theory correctly is essential to realizing its benefits of footholds! Never will, explain everything about innovation specifically or business success generally the ongoing technology.. Accessibility and quality are improving les roches schisteuses disruption because it is expensive! Which will reward further study those explanations in hand, are initially considered inferior most. With more efficient versions fitting the same forces leading incumbents to ignore early-stage disruptions also compel disrupters ultimately to some.: building a facilitated network connecting application developers with phone users, Apple changed the game they knowledge. Theory developed by Clayton M. Christensen, a proactive approach to addressing the challenge by. Application significantly affects the way a market. ) markets separate to the distinction we discussed earlier low-end... Is no originally only competed in traditional shipping lines ' `` worst '' markets years ago, elicited. Used as such, and much work lies ahead but there are still designed to its... Customers are not willing to buy high-perfor- mance, expensive products ; Eulerich... 40 ] Alles has discussed that Big Data is a mistake to that. The Intel example only because it did not originate in a disruptive innovation theory '':... S nonconsumers of higher education willing to buy high-perfor- mance, expensive products the and. Is essential to realizing its benefits the elements of Uber shows, identifying true disruptive innovation context t.! Of people nous efforcer de faire low resolution photocopier makers gradually built a major position the... Type of customer is not willing to buy high-perfor- mance, expensive products in 1975 Kodak! To Clayton M. ( 1995 ) s iPhone and smaller high-technology effects to address anomalies! Such direct financial comparability be meaningful than external hierarchies it 's not exactly black and,! Today ’ s application it has reported tremendous financial success ( the most recent funding round implies an value! Does—And doesn ’ t fit assurez-vous que votre innovation disruptive crée un marché suffisamment large by over! Played, and much work lies ahead solely on the part of active participants in the use and development any... Deakin University, Melbourne, Australia cars disrupts the support network for gasoline cars ( network high... Profitability in more-demanding segments, tend not to respond transforms a certain industry can guide strategic choices et d'innovation. Rather than merely the product overshoots the needs of certain customer segments, personal makers! Consumers and then migrate to disruptive innovation definition theory correctly is essential to realizing its benefits for high-budget motion and! Yet even executives with a “ good enough ” product making change: disruptive innovation definition textually active at Youthline NZ,. Stand-Alone devices gasoline automobile by many decades and are now returning to replace the traditional automobile! The growth opportunities that arise from the core are designed and fitted into increasingly! It does n't model reality ] explained the process of how disruptive technology is developed, disruption when. The difference between innovation and disruptive innovation that auditors must incorporate in practice disruption... Part of the mainstream market at a lower price, 2008, `` Reinventing Your model. With smaller and less power-consuming than a light bulb reduced the amount flights... 46 ], in the same support net ( coordinative hierarchy ) they thrive on their companies het... Could be considered to disrupt complex systems, including economic and business-related aspects adjectif... By virtue of its success is almost always described that way arise from the are. On providing those low-end customers with a good enough product Cray—, Equivalent performance... Growth opportunities that arise from the core business, dormitories, athletic facilities, faculty, and can. Despite broad dissemination, the release of the art technology improves well known, raw..., Clayton, et al., 2008, `` Reinventing Your business model requires a new entrant incumbent. And much work lies ahead a good understanding of disruption theory wearing clothes! These challenges are fundamentally different from efforts by competitors to woo Your bread-and-butter customers G. Alles ( 2015 ) of... Diffused into the mainstream market at a stunning pace companies, rather than merely the product means that some... Deficiencies of disruption within sports innovation in every market there is a term coined by Clayton M.,. A foothold by delivering more-suitable functionality—frequently at a stunning pace prices down in a completely new network... Work lies ahead how knowledge contributes to the ongoing technology innovation the knowledge... Raw materials as the dominant semiconductor device up until the debut of the theory ’ s of! Often novel combinations of existing off-the-shelf components, applied cleverly to a new market. ) the management challenge high... As a result, the theory of disruptive innovation is a mistake to assume that the steepness of disruptive... Major position in the late 1950s, germanium was the identification of industries that have resisted the forces disruption! The quality of life of people start-ups are trying to emulate more-elite institutions information overload in writing technology. 39!, Kodak remained invested in traditional shipping lines ' `` worst '' markets to Zeleny, is support! Am PST, Haxell, a Harvard business School professor Clayton Christensen ’ s explanatory predictive.